« Pollard redux: U.S. charges American with spying for Israel | Main | Is U.S. global power declining? »

April 23, 2008

Will Petraeus change Iran policy?

Nancy Youssef sends this on today's Central Command announcement:

The naming of Army Gen. David Petraeus, the top Iraqi commander, to head U.S. Central Command and Lt. Gen. Raymond T. Odierno, Petraeus' deputy, to become the new Iraq commander suggests that Secretary of Defense Robert Gates wants the counterinsurgency strategy the two men have championed to define U.S. relations in the region that Central Command oversees. That includes, among other nations, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran and Iraq.

The appointments come at a precarious time, both in Iraq and the region. Petraeus’ surge strategy, which led to a significant drop in violence, has been in peril in parts of Baghdad after Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al Maliki launched an offensive in Basra last month.

But Iran may be the bigger issue. During his congressional testimony earlier this month, Petraeus said Iran has been aggravating violence in Iraq, but stopped short of calling for U.S. military action against Iraq's eastern neighbor.

Petraeus' comments, however, were more hawkish than those of his predecessor, Adm. William “Fox” Fallon, who abruptly retired last month after Esquire published a story in which Fallon said he was standing in the way of a tougher policy toward Iran. Gates and Fallon both denied there was a rift, but Fallon said that the perception of one forced him to leave.

The appointment of Odierno as Iraq commander marks something of a redemption. He'd previously been criticized for having a ham-handed "kinetic" approach to warfare that lacked the subtlety counterinsurgency requires. His aggressive tactics against the insurgency in northern Iraq during his previous stint there are often blamed for inflaming tensions, rather than tamping them down.

But in his announcement, Gates said that Odierno had built strong relationships with the Iraqi leadership as Petraeus's No. 2 in Iraq.

Until Fallon’s retirement, Odierno was slated to be the Army’s vice chief of staff. Now that post will go to Lt. Gen. Peter Chiarelli, who during his service in Iraq was among the first commanders to recognize that U.S. killings of innocent Iraqis had helped fuel the insurgency. "I would argue in many instances we are our own worst enemy," he told me in June, 2006.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c64169e200e5520d25658834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Will Petraeus change Iran policy?:

Comments

Glen Johnson

War, war, war and more wars! Read "A People's History of the United States: 1492 - Present" by Howard Zinn. Why not a Dept. of Peace instead of War?? Peace, harmony and PURE love to everyone around the World and Universes.

glen in AZ
former teacher in Southern Indiana 1967-71

Sick in Indiana

Dear ur nightmare,

I am here because I was born here. This is my home, I have nowhere to go. It is bad here.

ur nightmare

AMERICA THE GREAT.....wish more people like Sick in Indiana would take his approach and just leave so we dont have to beat them down...Simple, u dont like it here.....GO HOME MORONS....so funny how all these people say how bad it is here....then why are u here....oh yeah....again repeat after me AMERICA THE GREAT

James

To everyone who has provided a comment, get real. Regardless of whether you're an "American hero" in the service, a liberal, conservative, pacifist, right-wing psycho, or other, you do not matter. Our Constitution is readily ripped apart and ignored. Deemed trivial and unaccommodating. No one cares about YOU. Get yours however necessary and look out for your family, because no one else is. The more you try to adhere to one ideology, thinking it will ensure your rightness in this debacle of times, the more you are fooling yourself. YOU don't matter in political, diplomatic, economic, or military affairs. However, you all love to chide each other on your differences and where your opinions rest on the "spectrum". Posting comments lets you get things off your chest, but it doesn't solve jack s%*t. Unless you know how to effectively feed, clothe, educate, or employ people for the duration, please do the world a favor, turn Idol back on and shut the f*$k up.

ur nightmare

To Ali Reza Idol.....don't even know where to begin with someone like u......so u say that u assure us (Iran the arrogant) can protect their interest! My friend Iran has no clue who they are messing with....just like sadaam....Amandinejad uses all this big talk cause thats all they got.....America can at anytime we choose erase that idiotic extremist culture(3000 years of digging in the sand maybe)we are 50 times more powerful and u know it....and u will see this when the time is right.....could end up being America #2 where Iran is now. Hell Israel alone could absolutely in one punch...lay Iran on their backs and you'll see that too!! So...mr medical writer....shut it!!!!

Michael

To quote an earlier comment "Generals should execute strategies devised by civilian leaders...".

Please read, "The Art of War" by Sun Tzu. It tells you why its NOT a good idea to have citizens involved in coflicts.

Sick in Indiana

Later today is the Democratic primary. I am going to vote and then leave this country. You all have inspired me. I honestly can not believe that most of you writing here are the people that represent us in the world. You might be thinking to yourself, "Good riddance to bad rubbish," well...such is life, I suppose. If I might suggest something to those of you who are of a right-wing disposition: Read either The Prince or The Art of War by a Florentine man by the name of Niccolo Macchiavelli. You will see that we are not on the right track. Good luck.

drw

killer64, May we sugest getting some professional help...

drw

and most of the rest just seem to be bush haters...
You make me sick

drw

Can't beleave how many of you sound like you actually hate our country...
God bless the USA and all of our brave men and women in uniform

The comments to this entry are closed.

ABOUT THIS BLOG

"Nukes & Spooks" is written by McClatchy correspondents Jonathan S. Landay (national security and intelligence), Warren P. Strobel (foreign affairs and the State Department), and Nancy Youssef (Pentagon).

jon, nancy & warren

Landay, Youssef and Strobel.

Send a story suggestion or news tip.
Read more stories by Jonathan Landay.
Read more stories by Warren Strobel.
Read more stories by Nancy Youssef.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

THIS MONTH

    Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3 4 5
    6 7 8 9 10 11 12
    13 14 15 16 17 18 19
    20 21 22 23 24 25 26
    27 28