Washington Post columnist Colbert King has prevailed in a defamation lawsuit filed by a prison inmate who claims King falsely linked him to a jailhouse murder and unfairly compared him to an al Qaeda terrorist.
In a 14-page opinion issued Friday, U.S. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson dismissed the $10 million-plus lawsuit filed by James H. Carpenter, Jr.
The 32-year-old Carpenter is serving a life sentence at the Federal Correctional Complex in Coleman, Fla. His complaint arose from three columns written in 2009 concerning the death of a 29-year-old District of Columbia native named Keith Barnes. Barnes was murdered by other inmates while in federal prison.
In one column, King cited courts documents as showing that "Carpenter wrote several letters to Barnes telling him he would be killed if he continued to cooperate" with police. King further suggested that the death of Barnes raised questions about whether prison officials were ready to handle dangerous al Qaeda prisoners.
Carpenter claimed that the columns were slanted to make him seem more dangerous than international terrorists, and further that the harmful columns would endanger his appeals because "the judges of the court system read the Washington Post."
Judge Jackson, without divulging her own newspaper reading habits, went through Carpenter's claim piece by piece and dismissed it, in part, because she said did not see a plausible claim that the statements in questions were false, defamatory and unprotected. A quick check of the PACER database suggests that this was the first defamation lawsuit filed against the Pulitzer Prize-winning King.