Allegations continue to mount that Israeli soldiers systematically committed war crimes during the 22-day military offensive in Gaza.
Following leaked testimony from Israeli soldiers who said their comrades killed civilians in Gaza, the United Nations has issued a new report prepared by human rights investigators who said they unearthed scores of questionable incidents.
The UN report said Israeli soldiers used an 11-year-old boy as a human shield, shelled a building after moving Palestinian civilians inside a day earlier, and used a bulldozer to bring another building down on top of a woman and child.
Along with the UN report, The Guardian has published an extensive report on alleged Israeli war crimes in Gaza.
The Guardian stories and video reports focused on evidence that Israeli soldiers used Palestinians as human shields and that Israeli drones killed two dozen Gazans during the offensive.
The Israeli military is looking into specific allegations raised by its own soldiers. But the IDF continues to categorically dismiss allegations raised by the UN, human rights groups and others.
Later this week, Human Rights Watch is planning to release its report on the Israeli military's controversial use of white phosphorus during the military operation.
As The New York Times recently noted, Israel is grappling with a "crisis of isolation" created by the Gaza offensive.
The NYT called it Israel's "worst diplomatic crisis in two decades."
Haaretz blogger Bradley Burston poses the question: "Why does the world media love to hate Israel?"
"Anyone who has been in a war, as a participant, reporter, or civilian bystander, knows that any war, every war, spawns war crimes," Burston writes. "The question, when examining the Cast Lead operation in Gaza, was whether there was something different, something exceptional and intentional and, especially, a matter of policy and command direction, that either trapped or targeted large numbers of civilians, resulting in a human tragedy far beyond the horrible reality of the very fact of warfare. Was, in other words, this war different from all other wars? Or was this war the trigger for an outpouring of anti-Israel animus that was, for lack of a better term, disproportionate? Although the jury is still out pending further independent inquiry, the likely answer to both is: Yes."
For the moment, Israeli leaders continue to reject increasing calls for independent investigations of the events in Gaza.
As Jeffrey Goldberg recently noted on his blog at The Atlantic:
"The crucial question is, how should a civilized country behave when confronting barbarism? With barbarism? Or with respect for innocent life? Pardon me for saying so, but the Jewish people didn't struggle for national equality, justice and freedom so that some of its sons could behave like Cossacks. Please don't get me wrong: I'm not equating the morality of the IDF to that of Hamas. The goal of Hamas is to murder innocent people; the goal of the IDF is to avoid murdering innocent people. But when the IDF fails to achieve its goal, and ends up inflicting needless destruction and suffering, it sullies not only its own name, but the name of the Jewish state. It risks making a just cause -- Jewish nationhood -- seem unjust, and it ultimately endangers what it is supposed to protect."

Maybe because the IDF was acting like Cossacks?
Posted by: borisjimbo | March 25, 2009 at 03:36 AM
I thought it odd that the article missed what seems to be the most important issue - If the goal of the IDF's action is to prevent terrorist attacks, their reckless and blatant disregard for the lives and possessions of the Palestinians not only undermines their goal but actually opposes it, making an unjust goal like terrorism seem more than just, in fact heroic!
Posted by: Pete | March 26, 2009 at 02:39 PM
The goal of Israel is to kill all Palestinians little by little so that it doesn't look like a genocide and get their land and make a great Israel. This is beyond belief that intelligent people like the Jews have been behaving like this for years and then each year they keep reminding us of their Holocaust.
Posted by: claudia | March 26, 2009 at 03:07 PM
I came to this story by the way of this one of yours: March 27, 2009 Story of ongoing pain. Maybe if you look at what the Arabs are doing to their own, You'd realize what are they doing and keep trying to do to the Jews. I quote: "I just can not understand why the insurgents target the civilians. They are not security forces like us. They don't cause any harm to anyone. They just want to live"
Posted by: Lipa Roitman | March 27, 2009 at 09:34 AM
There is no clear cut method in tackling cross border terrorism. Innocent people will be caught in the cross fire its inevitable. I Kashmir 100's of innocent people die in clashes between our army and terrorists. Terrorist will always use civilians as shields.
Posted by: rajini | March 27, 2009 at 01:41 PM
rajini - It is not a case of 'cross fire'. There are well documented, prima facie evidence of the improper use by Israeli forces of 'area weapons' such as mortar and artillery fire, white phosphorous and flechettes in highly populated areas of Gaza. There is also evidence of precision weapons - those requiring a chain of command before use - to directly attack unarmed civilians NOT participating in any hostilities.
Human rights violations by one party also cannot be used to justify human rights abuses by the other.
The collective punishment of 1.5 million people cannot justify indiscriminate rockets that are fired into southern Israel that kill and injure civilians while Hamas' tactics cannot justify indiscriminate and disproportional attacks by Israel.
Check out the three Guardian videos by Clancy Chassay for some information on these specific issues. [Click on my name for a simple link to these videos.] And also the Amnesty International site for their reports - www.amnesty.org as well as Human Rights Watch which just came out with a report on the use of white phosphorous - www.hrw.org.
Posted by: Edie | March 27, 2009 at 07:06 PM
It's amazing these IDF vets and prison-guards like Goldberg are actually sources. I mean seriously, how stupid is this: "The goal of Hamas is to murder innocent people; the goal of the IDF is to avoid murdering innocent people."
Look at the kill-rates of the IDF versus Hamas and imagine if someone tried to pass this stuff off as analysis on any other state in the world besides Israel. It's complete idiocy. Dion, you saw the newspapers and posters in Gaza during the disengagement in which Hamas bragged/propagandized that they'd killed more Israelis than any other faction - the number was 350. That's soldiers, settlers, reservists, police officers, and civilians. Since 1988: 350
Since running in elections, Hamas has killed how many Israeli civilians? Three. All during this last assault: 900 civilians to 3.
But for Goldberg, pardon me for saying it, the latest atrocity stirred his first pangs of moral sensitivity. maybe it was the 900 civilians to 3 this time around, or maybe it was the charred babies or disfigured burn victims pictures that did it. Whatever it was, he didn't notice the last 10 years of Palestinian death tolls of dozens to 1 -
2008: 450
2007: 316
2006: 657 (+1300 Lebanese)
2005: 190
2004: 819
2003: 573
2002: 989
2001: 453
2000: 272
Posted by: Todd Shishler | March 28, 2009 at 06:15 AM
The real outrage is that we give $8billion a year to Israel in free Taxpayer dollars.
They have a better standard of living than AMericans, who pay taxes.
Why do we fund a religious fundamentalist state full of racists with our hard earned money?
Why should our children pay so kids in a supposed first world country can have free health care while they are denied the same.
$8billion a year is enough to provide healthcare for all children in the US. We want our money back Israel, and Washington should start listening.
Posted by: no more us taxdollars for israel | March 30, 2009 at 10:58 AM
Palistianians shell Israel on a daily basis and nothing is said.......
Israel responds and is accused of war crimes.....
The communist filled UN is more the criminal!
Posted by: David | March 30, 2009 at 01:56 PM