Is it possible to vandalize vandalism?
OK, the works of celebrated graffiti artist Banksy probably can't be classified as vandalism anymore, but it's an interesting question that has no doubt been debated ad nauseum by graffiti artists around the world.
But what do you call it when someone vandalizes graffiti?
Whatever you call it, that's what's happened, or is happening, in Bethlehem, where some vandal has obliterated two of Banky's latest pieces of political wall art.
In the waning days of "Santa's Ghetto" someone has whitewashed Banky's silhouette of a soldier questioning a donkey and one of Banksy's signature rats with a slingshot.
Of course no one knows who is behind these dastardly deeds (in this part of the world, they might well be dubbed acts of artistic terrorism), but one prevailing theory is that the images were wiped out by Palestinians who took offense at the images.
Although Banksy pretty clearly meant to satirize Israeli security concerns with the soldier-donkey piece, calling someone a donkey in this part of the world is a pretty serious insult.
And some people (including, apparently, the guy whose house the image was painted on) who saw the soldier-donkey image thought Banksy was suggesting that Palestinians were donkeys.
Same thing goes for Banksy's signature rat with the slingshot - an image well known to Banksy fans.
Some people thought that Banksy was mocking Palestinians and comparing them to rats.
(Another one of Banksy's rats sold for $125,000 at the auction.)
A "Santa's Ghetto" organizer I met shrugged off the assault, but it does underscore some of the classic local-international tensions that sometimes arise when "outsiders" come in and attempt to draw attention to an issue "locals" have been working on their whole lives.
In any case, "Santa's Ghetto" has already succeed in attracting massive international media attention to Bethlehem this Christmas season.
The auction ends on Christmas Eve, but all the wall art will be staying as long as vandals don't obliterate it.
Here's some of the newer additions:
These posters are by Ron English.
Below is a piece by a Miami-born street artist named Swoon who now lives in New York and, like Banksy, keeps her identity under wraps.
Underneath the woman it reads:
When the Bay Bridge fell in the last San Francisco earthquake, we learned that structures resonate to a frequency. A vibration that matches their internal rhythm can bring them down. Massive structures tremble and a fence is only as strong as its point of attachment to its base.


Banksy Print - Difaced Ten Pound Notes
Hi All!
I have decided to sell some of my Banksy collection - These are Di-Faced Tenners.
They are in absolutely perfect condition (mint) and they have been stored in an acid free folder in my smoke free home.
I have uploaded photos here :
http://www.flickr.com/photos/banksyfreak/
There is also a video here on Youtube.
The video quality is no the best. Please see the photos for better detail.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPBWnYhnQvk
Feel free to email me - banksyfreak at gmail dot com
I ship with FedEx worldwide.
Payment accepted via PayPal =)
Thanks for your time !
Posted by: Bnaksy Freak | December 23, 2007 at 12:16 PM
Is it really surprising that Palestinians who have seen thousands of stone-throwing children killed were pissed that the ajnabi painted rats throwing stones? Is it really that big a leap for the Palestinians to make - or does Banksy think the whole world knows him because he culture-jams London overpasses with stenciled rats? And the donkey? What are people supposed to think? What has Banksy done for the benefit of the doubt? This from an idiot who in 2005 thought painting windows and horses into the wall was radical. Like a Palestinian told Banksy at the time: "Go home."
If Banksy only cares about his "art", fine. But atleast stop pretending you are political (let alone revolutionary) with your Adbusters stunts. Think for one minute about where you are, who is around you, what their lens is, what their experience is.. Ask yourself what is more important: to be in solidarity with hundreds of kids killed defending their shrinking ghetto with stones vs tanks, or to paint your rat stencils for a stupid auction.
Ps.. is it really that useful to "attention" to the birthplace of Jesus on Christmas? The whole thing is so obtuse it baffles.. and shames.
Posted by: Todd Shishler | December 25, 2007 at 02:09 AM
These Graffiti paintings are certainly an insult. The whole series of events that the Palestinians were subjected to are pure occupation, racism and apartheid. Starting from occupying Palestine to declaring a Jewish state and now to seggregation and insult.
Not a single Arab would believe Israel's declaration for Peace. On one hand they meet with Palestinians for Peace negotiations and simultaneously kill Palestinians and expand settlements.
The Israeli flag shows two blue lines depicting the Nile and the Euphrates. In between is the star of David expressing that the land of Israel is from the Nile to the Euphrates. For Israel to be serious on peace, it has to declare that this is no more its idealogy. Get rid of all these racist symbols.
Posted by: Izzat Sajdi | January 01, 2008 at 02:49 AM
These Graffiti paintings are certainly an insult. The whole series of events that the Palestinians were subjected to are pure occupation, racism and apartheid. Starting from occupying Palestine to declaring a Jewish state and now to seggregation and insult.
Not a single Arab would believe Israel's declaration for Peace. On one hand they meet with Palestinians for Peace negotiations and simultaneously kill Palestinians and expand settlements.
The Israeli flag shows two blue lines depicting the Nile and the Euphrates. In between is the star of David expressing that the land of Israel is from the Nile to the Euphrates. For Israel to be serious on peace, it has to declare that this is no more its idealogy. Get rid of all these racist symbols.
Posted by: Izzat Sajdi | January 01, 2008 at 02:51 AM