« Ramadan in Baghdad | Main | Important issues »

September 18, 2007

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c64169e200e54ef53b978834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference How many have died?:

Comments

fred

A poll conducted by D3 Systems for the BBC, ABC News, ARD German TV and USA Today included the question, "Q45 Do you think the separation of people on sectarian lines is a good thing or a bad thing for Iraq?" 6% of respondents thought it was a good thing; 94% thought it was a bad thing. This live-and-let-live attitude gets only rare mention in America, where the preferred belief has all Muslims/Arabs driven primarily by religious fervor.

Linda Spurlock

I understand both religions are based on the koran. Does it allow for killing of men, women and children of muslim faith?

Linda Spurlock

I understand both religions are based on the koran. Does it allow for killing of men, women and children of muslim faith?

Chris Baker

One problem, as Leila well knows, is the Democrats are able to significantly distort the reality in Iraq for political purposes. For example Democrats keep repeating their mantra that the US military shouldn't be between two sides in a "civil war".

As the Republicans largely don't talk about Iraq, and the media keeps repeating the Democrats allegations, a "civil war" in Iraq has become the reality for many Americans. A recent Pew poll found most Americans believe the US military is unable to prevent a "civil war" in Iraq by a 2-1 margin.

Jeff Stewart

A couple points:

How are the democrats distorting the reality in Iraq...if they were, wouldnt they be successful in creating the conditions for bringing the troops home? Republicans not talking about Iraq doesnt change the fact of a civil war. Do a google on "civil war" and you will see Iraq is in one and has been for some time.

2) It is pathetic to me that the generals are openly participating in the public relations effort to sell this occupation. Not surprising - Petraeu is openly political - from writing Op-Eds before elections to skewing statistics, he is betraying his own professionalism. Move-On is castigated for simply asking the question: should a general stick to the facts or sell a bad policy?

3) This may sound ridicuolusly elementary, but how does one tell the difference between a Sunni and a Shia...? Is it a surname thing? Last I checked they were all the same race. So I guess this isnt ethnic cleansing.

So many questions, so few answers.

Jeff

Jeff Stewart

A couple points:

How are the democrats distorting the reality in Iraq...if they were, wouldnt they be successful in creating the conditions for bringing the troops home? Republicans not talking about Iraq doesnt change the fact of a civil war. Do a google on "civil war" and you will see Iraq is in one and has been for some time.

2) It is pathetic to me that the generals are openly participating in the public relations effort to sell this occupation. Not surprising - Petraeu is openly political - from writing Op-Eds before elections to skewing statistics, he is betraying his own professionalism. Move-On is castigated for simply asking the question: should a general stick to the facts or sell a bad policy?

3) This may sound ridicuolusly elementary, but how does one tell the difference between a Sunni and a Shia...? Is it a surname thing? Last I checked they were all the same race. So I guess this isnt ethnic cleansing.

So many questions, so few answers.

Jeff

tussi

i suggest you recomend to the iraqi terrorists to stop killing there own fellow iraqis,this is daily news worldwide.muslims of the world unite.reap vengence on the al-quida terroroists who blow themselfs up and kill poor iraqi GOD fearing people.long live iraqi civilization

gale

It's a common veiw in Australia (not one held by myself) that Iraqi's have been fighting amongst themselves for decades, that they can't form a govt. because of it & the Americans are there to sort it....So wrong! but the people here have litte understanding and only go by what the mainstream media portray...media coincidently owned by america

John Abbott

Do you realize that you wrote:
"I couldn't believe it, doesn't he know? Sunnis and Shiites don't necessarily hate each other in Iraq but right now they have no choice but to fear each other."

First you wrote that they don't necessarily hate each other... and then you go on to suggest that the general is off his rocker for clearing the air on that matter.
Leila, as a reporter, you are letting your own personal bias affect how you write.
If that one statement there doesn't make it clear to you, nothing will. That's coming from a PJ student.

Please re-evaluate how you are letting your own opinions of how people "should" think affect how you write.
There are people who will die if you are not accurate. That's what the general was trying to tell you. That same fear that you complain about is being fueled by you, even when you admit that Sunnis and Shiites don't hate each other.

-John

John Abbott

To Jeff Stewart;
Yes, if you Google "civil war" and "iraq" you'll find that Iraq is in a civil war. -And if you Google "9/11" and "bomb" you'll find that 9/11 was a conspiracy by the government to take us to war.
My point is that just because you can Google it, it doesn't make it true.
There have been several polls taken of Iraqis where the majority of Iraqis do not believe that they are in a civil war.
Don't you think that they would know, if they were?

The re-definition of what's going on in Iraq into a civil war was done a year ago, when the Democrats wanted to make an argument to get out. They couldn't argue that we should leave terrorists alone, so instead, they talked about how "civil war" was coming. It was imminent.
Its still, apparently, imminent, a year later.

So yeah, I argue with your concept of civil war.

-John

The comments to this entry are closed.

ABOUT THIS BLOG

Baghdad Observer is written by McClatchy journalists staffing the Baghdad bureau.

Feel free to send a story suggestion. Read their stories at news.mcclatchy.com.

THIS MONTH

    Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
              1 2
    3 4 5 6 7 8 9
    10 11 12 13 14 15 16
    17 18 19 20 21 22 23
    24 25 26 27 28 29 30
    31