« Important issues | Main | TO GO OR NOT TO GO »

September 21, 2007

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c64169e200e54ee41e388833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Beyond Blackwater:

Comments

Laura

(In no particular order). Ireland. Rwanda. Cambodia. South Africa. Darfur. Somalia. Germany. USSR. USA. Turkey. Greece. Israel. Palestine. And on and on, through the ages....the hardest (it seems) thing for us humans to do: to learn to forgive. The other hardest thing: to love one another in the first place, not to exploit, so there is less pain caused that requires forgiveness.
My country is one of--if not THE--biggest exploiters. We have no right to preach about forgiveness, who should be asking for it, and doing our best to make repairs.

My hope is that we each will one day see one another as dear simply because we are human. And no longer look upon the other as blood to exploit or avenge upon.

Some people have learned how to do this. If only teachers would step forward now to help....

Linda Spurlock

I am sick of it all. At the beginning I supported the end of a dictatorship. However, religion will always be the dictator of this and all muslim countries. Believe as they do or die. They do not want to change; it is the only life they have ever known. You can defeat a country and set up a government but you cannot defeat a religion which rules so completely. It is is an inside job. We need to get out..........NOW! All military...all contractors....they think they don't need anybody and we are "invaders". I am sick of this. I was a teenager in the sixties and lived through the vietnam war. What a waste of life, and now, is this again another waste of life. To die for someone who would kill you in a minute.

Laura

We had--and have--no right to defeat any country. And never any right to defeat a religion. We had no right invade Iraq nor any right now to blame Iraqis for the woe into which they have been cast.

And revenge killings and hatred of the beliefs of others are HUMAN traits, not Muslim ones.

We all must learn how to supplant anger with love, hurt and fear with forgiveness. And for no one is that an easy thing.

Chris Baker

The key to getting Shi'a and Sunni living and working together again is going to be the Iraqi army, not the clerics. Getting Shi'a, Sunni, Kurds. etc. serving together in military units is perhaps the most important undertaking in Iraq. That's why the US military is pushing so hard for more Sunni's to serve in predominantly Shi'a brigades.

The US military has direct experience with this because they know how difficult it was to "integrate" US military units starting in 1948 - for the previous 140 years African-Americans served in separate units. However with an executive order by the President in 1948, the US military was successfully integrated. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_9981

Also the polls of Muslim countries show a rapid decline in support for terrorism against civilians, with a couple of exceptions like the Palestinians. It's indicative of how Islam is changing and perhaps there will be even more change as a result of what is being accomplished in Iraq. That's why it's such an important endeavor.

Linda Spurlock

Chris, I would like so much to believe in what you are saying. I am afraid that these troops/contractors will be used as election ploys both in the United Stated but also in the unstable Iraqi government. In the blending of multiple islam religions into one country with one army. How long of a period of time is involved?

billjpa

who will pay? thats easy!The people will pay!Who else? today its Iraq, tomorrow where? Iran, syria, -Oh, and let us not forget Africa! Anywhere a profit can be made!
The Great God Profit!!!

TomW

So many reactions are emotional rants and mea kulpas but the Iraq question is so much more complicated. The US took out Saddam and its hard to stick up for him and his brand of genocide, or to talk about him as the good old days. The Iraqi people have a chance to found a nation and they can if right can prevail. So often religion is used as a means of legitamizing violence and evil. What ever happend to religion? It was once a force for good and now seems to be involved in some much evil and hatred around the world. I know many who have served in Iraq and many speak lovingly of the Iraqis and talk of the middle class and the intellectuals who want to have a nation that encompasses the the two major Islamic sects but it seems impossible. The clerics are blood thirsty and power hungry and the nation seems unable to comprehend how they are being used. I think the troops should leave. They have done so much there that is good (and unreported) but it make not make a difference. The Iraqis have to stand on their own and now. I have hope for them but I know they face foreign forces and truly people interested in the oil wealth. But we cannot ask this young American Army to do more. The UN maybe? Haha no chance there.

The comments to this entry are closed.

ABOUT THIS BLOG

Baghdad Observer is written by McClatchy journalists staffing the Baghdad bureau.

Feel free to send a story suggestion. Read their stories at news.mcclatchy.com.

THIS MONTH

    Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
              1 2
    3 4 5 6 7 8 9
    10 11 12 13 14 15 16
    17 18 19 20 21 22 23
    24 25 26 27 28 29 30
    31